Blog Details

28 October 2024 1 Ms Roshini Easow

India Cooling Action Plan recommends that the temperature setting of the Air conditioner has to be at 24oC and this is discussed at length in many forums. Many a time we hear of the 1 degree challenge and we (ISHRAE members) have even taken oath (during an NBoG) that the setting should be at 27oC.  Everyone is aware that this is to reduce the energy input required for cooling. At the same time it is understood that the main aim of an air conditioner is to keep the human in a state of thermal comfort.

Humans are heat engines. The human body constantly generates heat as a byproduct of metabolic processes. This heat needs to be regulated to maintain the body's core temperature within a relatively narrow range for optimal physiological function. A human body loses heat primarily through four mechanisms: radiation, conduction, convection, and evaporation

The surface area of an average human body is 1.5 to 2.0sq.m.  The normal body temperature (as measured by a clinical thermometer ) is around 37oC but the skin is at an average temperature of 33oC. The body has to reject heat to the surroundings but the clothing we wear provides insulation, following Q= U A ?T,  if U is low then ?T has to be high for same Q to happen.

The insulation due to clothing is termed as the ‘clo’value where 1 clo = 0.155 K·m2·W−1 

The higher the clo value, more is the insulation due to clothing.  Eg. See some representative values in the table below

Garment Insulation Values (clo)

Skirt

0.14

Short sleeve shirt

0.19

Straight Trousers

0.24

Long sleeve shirt

0.25

Suit Jacket

0.42

 

 

As can be seen, the common so called ‘formal wear’ has a higher insulation effect.  

Coming back to the heat loss mechanism of sweating and its evaporation, it is just common sense that the clothing unless it is absorbent and brings out the sweat by capillary action like in a fabric like cotton, it will not serve its function.  The relative humidity of the surrounding air also needs to be low for moisture transfer to take place.

It is commonly believed that the jacket and tie is the ‘business wear’ but one can see that it is counterproductive in our quest for energy efficiency.  Our Middle Eastern friends do business in their traditional wear so why not we Indians too?

In closing it is really heartening to see these lines from the notification for an ASHRAE event in September “We therefore request you to dress up accordingly and wear smart casuals made out of Cotton only. No Jacket or tie is required for any of the events.”

Comment(1)

Mr. Krishnan Viswanath
05 Nov 2024

Hey Roshini, Your suggestion that we have the Temp Set Point at 80 deg F may have issues in places like Bombay. With 80 deg F as Room Set Point, the SA Temp will be around 60 deg F. With the kind of ADP needed to achieve this you may have insufficient de-humidification. Shouldn't we say 80 deg F to be considered at elevated Room Air Velocities ? If you have 80 deg F with standard recommended 50 FPM in Occupied Zone will be thermally uncomfortable. Maybe, you should be considering higher Room Air Velocities (easy to calculate) using Effective Draft Temperature equations. Krishnan krishnan@dynacraftindia.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *